CSCE 452/752 Robotics and Spatial Intelligence, Fall 2025

Homework 8 Solutions

Ben claims to be an expert on PID control. He says:
“We can only use PID control if the system model $\dot{x} = f(x, u)$ is known. Otherwise, we do not know how the states will change over time, can therefore cannot solve for the gains $K_p$, $K_i$, and $K_d$.”
Is Ben's claim correct? Circle one.
YES    NO
Explain your answer.
Ben's claim is NOT CORRECT. The gains in PID controller are generally tuned experimentally, and the system model is not required.
The idea of solving the system model equation for $K_p$, $K_i$, and $K_d$ does not make much sense, since those gains do not appear in a typical system model equation.
Note that the system model can make predictions about how the state will change in the future, which is a different question from whether the robot can observe the states as they occur. The latter is what we need to use PID control.
Finally, recall that the whole point of feedback control is that we may not have an accurate description of how the states will change in response to actions.